Talk:The Angler's Guide to Fishing in LotRO
Options
View source
History
What links here
Related changes
Special pages
Permanent link

Hi fellow Anglers! This is just a placeholder as I figure out how this Lorebook Discussion page works. I'm looking forward to the great back-and-forth here that made the original Guide on the Forums such a success. If you swing through here, please drop a line. I'd love to see how this all works.

-- Harry

Contents

Guide

looking at the Guide. Looks great and the Visual Guide is also very good. In the your Bug section, you might add DH's comment about the 50 LB Salmon, trading it to someone and having them make it into the trophy gives them the Title.

Keep up the good job.

RE: Guide

Thanks! The salmon thing is a big exploit that's finally getting patched & fixed in the new Book 14. Once Book 14 is live I'll confirm all the Fishing fixes and then remove them from the bug list.

New Fishing Title in book 14

Trout - Master

Deed opens after catching any 1 of the 9 rare Trout.

Completion of the deed rewards you with the title and a new Trout Group Trophy (a trophy comprised of the complete trout group)

Re: Trout Master

Oh wow, that's great. I'm glad they decided to do something fun with the zone-specific guys. Thanks for posting!

I'm going to hold off updating the Guide until Book 14 goes live, just to make sure it still makes it in. (Same with all the bug fixes that Turbine's mentioned -- want to make sure they're reall fixed.)

New banner

Cheers for the nice new banner Clover!

You are welcome :)

I made it yesterday. I think it makes the articles look much neater:)Clover

New Tables

I made some new table templates while I was working over on the DDO compendium this week. I thought they would make your page easier to read. Please feel free to revert it if you do not agree. :)

New tables

Yah, those new tables have a nice punch to them. Good call, and thanks.

- Harry/Aethelberht

Congratulations!

A superb guide that deserves the recognition. Congrats on your spiffy new Forum Title! Now you don't have to link it in your signature. :-D

Figgy

Agreed, congrats!

Your guide is exemplary. I'm glad you liked that title better than the other, too. ;) Patience

Thanks!

Thanks for the kudos. And I'm definitely taking to my title, much like Kramer took to the vanity plate in that episode of "Seinfeld"!

aethelberht

Great guide. There is one thing I would take issue with, and did not see any associated data. That is the basic number of fish caught per hour with bait vs without bait (without respect to type of fish caught). My own experience around level 140+ was that I caught quite a few more fish per hour with red wigglers than without bait. Perhaps one can extrapolate this data from the figures given pertaining to specific types of fish caught but it would be much easier if there were numbers for the basic number of fish caught w/ w/o bait per hour.

Thanks, Simpson Rumfigger, Lord of the Streams

Discussion Forum


NOTE: I'm looking forward to hearing & learning more from fellow anglers now that Mines of Moria has gone live. For any questions/comments/discussion/advice/help/whatever, please see the original postin the LOTRO General Forums. It is a much more robust, secure place for discussion than the "Discussion" tab at this wiki. Thanks! Harry/aethelberht